Large Pharmaceutical And Biotechnology Companies May Feast On The Small- And Mid-Cap Biotechs In 2007
Jason Zhang, Ph.D. Analyst Prudential Equity Group, LLC
Our fearless prediction for biotechnology in 2007 is that more small- to mid-cap
biotech companies will be acquired by either large pharmaceutical (pharma) or
large biotech companies. We believe the recently announced acquisitions (Figure
1) are only the start of more acquisitions to come in 2007.
Biotech companies are being acquired by large pharma for several reasons. First,
a huge disparity of market capitalization continues between large pharma and biotech
companies, making the pharma-biotech purchase relatively easy on the books. Even
after the recent market-cap shrinkage of large pharma and the incredible market-value
growth of several biotech companies, the total market cap of the large pharma
companies (14 largest) is still approximately 4 times the total market cap of
all listed (about 430) biotechs. If we take out the top-10 biotech companies,
the ratio is a stunning 10 times. The total market cap of biotech companies, excluding
the top 10, is about $150 billion, which is about equivalent to GlaxoSmithKline
plc, the second-largest pharma company in the world. As a result, the purchasing
power of large pharma companies, either in paper money or hard cash, is enormous
relative to the market valuation of biotechs.
Second, large pharma is starving for pipeline additions. Large pharma is realizing
that its thirst for products, particularly in the late stage, can be quenched
by biotechs. More often than not, large pharma companies prefer product licensing
and collaboration over outright acquisition. This approach hedges the downside
financial risk if a drug does not work out in clinical trials, and it provides
meaningful upside potential if the drug is approved. As an increasing amount of
large pharma companies jump into this game and the supply of attractive products
decreases, the price tag for licensing and collaboration increases dramatically
(Figure 2). Furthermore, more biotech companies want to hold on to the U.S. marketing
rights or demand 50/50 profit split in the major markets. These developments force
more large pharma companies to entertain the idea of outright acquisition, particularly
if the target company has more than one attractive product or an attractive technology
platform.
Finally, the strategic changes in many large pharma companies in the last few
years have made them more acceptable to companies with products in specialty markets.
Not long ago, the product licensing and acquisitions of many pharma companies
were limited to $1-$2 billion. A product needed to have that kind of revenue potential
to justify large pharma’s huge, predominantly primary-care sales force. However,
once pharma companies realized that such products were hard to produce, they restructured
their sales organization to be more aligned with specialty markets in which a
small but highly focused sales organization could generate more profitable revenue.
As these pharma companies’ R&D pipeline rarely had these “specialty” drugs, they
eagerly turned to biotech companies, which happened to have plenty of such drug
candidates in development.
It would be difficult for us to predict which company was going to be acquired,
and by whom, because large pharma companies acquire biotechs for different reasons.
In general, most of the deals that occurred in the last few years have involved
biotech companies that have had active product collaborations with a pharma company;
have held a product that was best-in-class or first-in-class or was a threat to
a major drug within a pharma company; or had a technology platform that could
be widely adopted to increase R&D output. When considering all of these criteria,
we think the following companies in our coverage universe are the most likely
to be acquired.
MedImmune, Inc.
click the image to enlarge
Why Is It An Attractive Target? MedImmune manufactures and sells Synagis,
an antibody used as a prophylaxis to prevent RSV infection in premature babies.
Sales of the drug will be more than $1 billion for 2006, and we see no meaningful
competition for the next five years. The company has shown that a second-generation
antibody, Numax, could be slightly more effective than Synagis. If approved and
launched, Numax, at a minimum, could extend the patent protection by more than
10 years and is more profitable than Synagis. At best, the drug may even expand
beyond Synagis’s current market, to be used as a treatment of RSV infection. In
short, the Synagis/Numax franchise should give the company a well-protected and
very profitable stream of cash flows.
In addition, MedImmune is to receive royalties on two HPV vaccines, one from Merck
and another from GlaxoSmithKline. With estimated combined sales of $4 billion
at their peaks, MedImmune could receive up to $300 million per year.
click the image to enlarge
Select Pharma-biotech partnerships: valuations and numbers
Furthermore, we think the company’s flu franchise could turn around in 2007 with
an expanded label to include children as young as one year old. Given that the
vaccine has shown better efficacy than a traditional flu shot, sales of the vaccine
could be substantial in the next few years as the government and the public get
more serious about preventing flu infection in the U.S.
Who Are The Likely Acquirers? We think Merck is the most logical acquirer
of MedImmune. Merck could do a better job of selling Synagis and save the royalty
on its HPV vaccine it has to pay MedImmune. Merck would also find the flu vaccine
business attractive. Given that MedImmune has a huge R&D budget, the deal could
even be accretive to Merck if Merck cuts the R&D significantly.
What Are The Potential Acquirers Waiting For? We would argue MedImmune’s
valuation is not particularly high given the assets the company has. What a potential
acquirer may be waiting for is the FDA decision on the flu vaccine’s label, which
should become available in late May 2007. A positive decision by the FDA would
eliminate the last hurdle remaining before we see a very successful flu vaccine
franchise.
Vertex Pharmaceuticals
Why Is It An Attractive Target? Vertex’s main drug is telapravir (VX-950)
for the treatment of chronic hepatitis C. This is an oral drug that has shown
unprecedented antiviral activity and could change the current paradigm of treatment
by both shortening the treatment duration from one year to about three to six
months and increasing the cure rate from about 45% to 75% or higher. We think
the global HCV treatment market could be $8 billion, and telapravir’s peak sales
could reach $3 billion.
Who Are The Likely Acquirers? Roche Holding AG and Schering-Plough are
the leaders with drugs already sold for HCV. Novartis AG, Merck, Bristol-Myers
Squibb (, Boehringer Ingelheim, Abbott Laboratories, and Johnson & Johnson, or
J&J are all seriously developing drugs for this disease and could all be potential
suitors of Vertex. J&J could be the front-runner considering its collaboration
with Vertex for telapravir’s rights outside of the U.S. In addition, Novartis,
Merck, and GSK all have had collaborations with Vertex on different projects.
Outside of the traditional large pharma companies, a biotech giant such as Gilead
Sciences could also be an acquirer because of its stronghold in the HIV drug market.
What Are The Potential Acquirers Waiting For? 2007 should be a very important one for the drug because a series of efficacy data from several ongoing Phase II trials will become available. In addition, safety data of the drug, first by the end of 2006 and more in 2007, from a total of 1,000 patients will also be available. With these two sets of data, the drug’s efficacy and safety should become a null question, even though the company may still have to run a Phase III. We think any acquirer would welcome that kind of assurance given the high valuation of this deal. On the other hand, an $8-billion acquisition (assuming a 50% premium over the current price) of a company with a drug that could achieve $3 billion worldwide sales, as well as several other drugs that are also promising, is not necessarily expensive.
Talkback! Pharmaceutical Processing is pleased to provide you an opportunity to share your opinions on any of the news stories or articles on our site. We reserve the right to edit/remove comments.